Monday, Sep 28, 2020 | Last Update : 12:03 PM IST

188th Day Of Lockdown

Maharashtra1339232103001535571 Andhra Pradesh6756746050905708 Tamil Nadu5808085251549313 Karnataka5755664622418582 Uttar Pradesh3870853258885594 Delhi2711142366515235 West Bengal2474252169214781 Odisha209374173571850 Telangana1872111564311107 Bihar178882164537888 Kerala175385117917678 Assam169985139977655 Gujarat1332191132403417 Rajasthan1288591077181441 Haryana1237821059901307 Madhya Pradesh117588932382207 Punjab107096840253134 Chhatisgarh9856566860777 Jharkhand7770964515661 Jammu and Kashmir69832495571105 Uttarakhand4533233642555 Goa3107125071386 Puducherry2548919781494 Tripura2412717464262 Himachal Pradesh136799526152 Chandigarh112128677145 Manipur9791760263 Arunachal Pradesh8649623014 Nagaland5768469311 Meghalaya5158334343 Sikkim2707199431 Mizoram178612880
  Opinion   Edit  30 Jul 2020  AA Edit | Governor must play by the Constitution

AA Edit | Governor must play by the Constitution

Published : Jul 30, 2020, 7:00 pm IST
Updated : Jul 30, 2020, 7:00 pm IST

The Supreme Court has made it abundantly clear that the governor has no discretionary power when it comes to calling a session of the house

Kalraj Mishra (PTI)
 Kalraj Mishra (PTI)

It is time Rajasthan governor Kalraj Mishra stopped playing unconstitutional games and instead summoned the session of the state legislature as recommended by the council of ministers.

Article 174 (1) of the Constitution states that “the Governor shall from time to time summon the House or each House of the Legislature of the State to meet at such time and place as he thinks fit..”


The Constitution has vested that power on the governor not thinking that the representative of the President would be a better judge than the council of ministers which is collectively responsible to the state legislature elected by the people on such matters. It was a procedural etiquette, nothing more than that.

If he construes it as a blank cheque given by the founding fathers to the occupants of gubernatorial offices, then he must disabuse himself of such thoughts.

Such misreading of the Constitution could make him also think that the ministers continue in their offices at his whim and fancy as Article 161 (1) says “the ministers shall hold office during the pleasure of the Governor”. The right reading of the term ‘pleasure’ is the period when a person has the confidence of the legislature.


The governor is constitutionally bound by the “aid and advice” of the ministry in the exercise of his functions, “except in so far as he is by or under this Constitution required to exercise his functions or any of them in his discretion.”

The Supreme Court has made it abundantly clear that the governor has no discretionary power when it comes to calling a session of the house.  

The governor setting conditions for the Assembly session to meet is also unheard of. The power to run the affairs of the state, leave alone the assembly, is with the people of the state, through their representatives.

All that the governor is expected to see if it is done as per the mandate of the Constitution and then report to the President. He can intervene if the Constitution and the law are violated, for he takes the oath to preserve, protect and defend them.


The governor must either cite an unconstitutional or illegal act by the council of ministers for stalling its recommendations or go by its advice. He does not have too many options. By refusing to go by it, the governor is acting against the will of the people of Rajasthan.

Like most Indian states, Rajasthan is also in the grip of the pandemic Covid-19. Even well-governed states which have marshalled all their might are finding it tough to keep the virus at bay, and Rajasthan is no exception.

The people of the state have a right to get the undivided attention of their government in this critical moment.

They have elected their representatives to decide how this job must be done. The governor must not come in the way of them sitting together and decide what is best for the state and the people. He must return to playing by the Constitution.


Tags: kalraj mishra, rajasthan government