New Delhi: A Delhi court has refused to set aside Rs 4,000 maintenance awarded to a woman from her estranged husband in a domestic violence case, saying it was not harsh considering the cost of living in the city.
The court pronounced the order while dismissing the plea of a man against a magisterial court verdict directing him to pay the amount to his wife as monthly maintenance.
“Keeping in view the cost of living index in metropolitan cities like Delhi, Rs 4,000 per month awarded to the respondent (wife) by the metropolitan magistrate cannot be held to be unjust or harsh,” additional sessions judge Lokesh Kumar Sharma said.
The court also rejected his claim of having no income and that his parents and minor daughter were dependent on him.
“I find it to be a very funny ground that despite claiming to be having no income, the appellant (husband) is claiming his parents and his minor daughter being dependent upon him. Once a person has no income, how can others be considered dependent on him, is a hard fact to digest.
“It is settled preposition of law and is recognised by the superior courts, time and again, that an able-bodied man is presumed to be capable of maintaining his wife and other family members as per the status enjoyed by him in the society,” the judge said. The court, however, set aside the monthly maintenance in favour of their minor daughter considering that she was already living with her father.
A magisterial court had on March 4, 2016, ordered the man to pay Rs 4,000 as monthly maintenance to his wife who had lodged a domestic violence complaint against him alleging she was thrown out of her matrimonial home for insufficient dowry.
