Saturday, Dec 04, 2021 | Last Update : 10:42 PM IST

  Opinion   Oped  26 Oct 2019  Patriotic Trump: To impeach or not?

Patriotic Trump: To impeach or not?

Aakar Patel is Executive Director of Amnesty International India. A former editor, Patel is a senior columnist and a translator of Urdu and Gujarati works.
Published : Oct 27, 2019, 12:05 am IST
Updated : Oct 27, 2019, 12:05 am IST

Presidents are immune from crimes committed while they are in office but they can be removed through the process of impeachment.

US President Donald Trump  (Photo: AP)
 US President Donald Trump (Photo: AP)

Samuel Johnson, who compiled the English dictionary, once said: “Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel.” Meaning that any crime and any misbehaviour was tolerated as long as it was committed by one who kept shouting that he loved his country. And on the other hand, the individual who questioned the behaviour of the country or government was a traitor, no matter how noble the person was. In our time and in our country this is true also. I will come to that later, but first let us look at what is happening in the United States. President Donald Trump is about to be impeached by the House of Representatives. The US Senate will then decide whether to acquit or convict him.

Presidents are immune from crimes committed while they are in office but they can be removed through the process of impeachment. Bill Clinton was impeached by a Republican majority House but acquitted by the Senate a couple of decades ago, and such things are determined more by party politics than by actual guilt. Mr Trump has been accused since being elected of being in collusion with Vladimir Putin. It is indisputable now that Russia has maliciously interfered with, influenced and obstructed the democratic process in America. Using the social media and fake news, it helped ensure that Hillary Clinton lost the 2016 election and Mr Trump won. Both the CIA and the FBI under Mr Trump have said this.


Following the various revelations, it was decided to set up an independent investigation under the former FBI director Robert Mueller to look at Russian interference. After the Mueller report, a number of Trump associates were convicted for wrongdoing. The list included Michael Flynn, Mr Trump’s national security adviser, who was jailed for lying to the FBI. Rick Gates, Mr Trump’s deputy campaign manager, who was guilty of conspiracy against the United States and making false statements to FBI agents. George Papadopoulos, a Trump foreign policy adviser, was jailed for making false statements to the FBI about his contacts with Russians during the campaign. Michael Cohen, Mr Trump’s lawyer and fixer, pleaded guilty to lying to Congress about the 2016 presidential campaign. Paul Manafort, Mr Trump’s campaign chairman, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy against the US and conspiracy to obstruct justice, is also in jail.


Mr Trump’s son and son-in-law have been in meetings with Russian operatives. Some of the Russians in the meetings have also been convicted of spying, showing this was endemic. But the illegal activity does not end there. Mr Trump has used campaign money to pay off women that he had slept with, and that is illegal. Now it has become clear that he was blackmailing Ukraine to taking action against his rival Joe Biden by withholding a military aid package passed by the US Congress. In every way, he has undermined the democratic process and acted against the interests of his nation.

But through all of this drama, it is Mr Trump who is pretending to be the nationalist and the patriot. It is his slogan that says “Make America Great Again”, though he is clearly acting against his nation’s interests. After whistleblowers in his administration alerted Congress to the Ukraine call, Mr Trump turned around and accused them of acting against the nation’s interests. He calls them the “deep state”, alleging that they want to take control and undermine democracy. The facts are clear about who is doing the illegal activity, but the facts do not seem to stop the side backing Mr Trump from saying that it is they who are acting against the anti-nationals. They use the hatred of immigrants and Muslims as the primary weapon to mobilise their base and any illegal action that they take is forgiven because they take this extreme position.


Because Mr Trump is still popular with certain parts of American society, especially white working class men and women, his party is doing the cowardly thing. Most of them are either running away or enabling and defending his behaviour. There seems to be no defence against the false patriot who peddles slogans.

This is a cautionary tale. It is what happens to countries where the mad and rabid narrative of nationalism takes over, as it has also done in India. The facts have become unimportant and useless. What is important is the constant shouting of patriotism, even as one undermines the interests of the people. And the abusing of rivals as being traitors. Just like in India, the media is also a participant. Mr Trump has strong backing through all of his wrongdoing from particular news channels. The newspapers which tend to be more fact-based, he has declared war against. This week, Mr Trump ordered the banning of the New York Times and the Washington Post from all federal offices. This is the level of pettiness one descends to through the defence of bogus nationalism.


It has become an acceptable substitute for actual patriotism, which means a love of the people and not a hatred of something. And it is very difficult to remove from the system once it is inserted, as America is finding out.

Tags: donald trump, patriotism